New UK Settlement Proposals: What They Mean for Migrants
The UK Government has published its response to the consultation on its proposed “Earned Settlement” framework, outlining significant changes to how migrants may qualify for indefinite leave to remain (ILR) in the future. While these proposals have not yet been incorporated into the Immigration Rules, they clearly indicate the Government’s intended implementation.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The proposed changes have not yet been incorporated into the Immigration Rules and may be amended before implementation.
The 5 new mandatory requirements for UK settlement
Under the proposals set out in the response, all applicants seeking to apply for settlement in the UK will now need to meet 5 mandatory requirements, regardless of the route they are applying under.
The 5 mandatory requirements are:
- The applicant must demonstrate good character and suitability
- The applicant must not have any outstanding Government debt
- The applicant must demonstrate strong English language ability
- The applicant must be able to evidence that they have passed the Life in the UK Test
- The applicant must demonstrate sustained contribution to the UK
Whilst these are mandatory requirements, they seem to reflect the overarching requirements already in place for certain routes. Therefore, there may not be much difference between the new proposals and the current rules for the eligibility criteria. The main difference is the effect of “earned” settlement and a shift in the benchmarks.
A shift from automatic to “earned” settlement
One of the most significant proposed changes is the extension of the standard settlement pathway from 5 years to 10 years. Rather than settlement being granted primarily based on time spent in the UK, applicants would need to demonstrate they have “earned” settlement through a combination of:
- Character and suitability
- Financial and economic contribution
- Integration and English language requirements
- Residence and qualifying visas
Character and suitability
The Government proposals confirm that criminality and specified debts owed to the Government will prevent settlement; however, immigration breaches will extend the pathway to settlement.
UK and overseas criminal records
The Government has confirmed that criminality will not be offset by other requirements such as higher earnings or other positive contributions. In “A Fairer Pathway to Settlement”, the Government has confirmed that any adult with a criminal record in the UK will be refused settlement.
Overseas convictions will also be taken into consideration, and the applicant will be refused where the conduct would constitute a criminal offence in the UK. However, discretion will be applied to take into account differences in legal systems, including where activity is criminalised overseas but is not a criminal offence in the UK.
Immigration breaches and the 20-year route
Specified immigration breaches will extend the pathway to settlement, placing the applicant on a 20-year route. Some of the breaches the Home Office is considering adding to the Immigration Rules will include:
- Overstaying
- Breaching a condition attached to permission
- Using deception in an application
- Taking action to frustrate immigration controls
Financial and economic contribution
The Home Office has confirmed that they will take multiple types of contributions into account, such as:
- Earnings
- Eligible health and education occupations
- Household income and British connection
- The applicant’s access to public funds during their qualifying period
Different types of routes to settlement based on contributions
There are factors that the Home Office will consider as part of an application, and whether they qualify for a faster route to settlement:
- Three-year route: Available for the highest economic contributors, and you must be earning £125,141 for a period of three years before applying.
- Five-year route: Remains available for those in certain categories such as:
- Higher earners earning at least £50,271 annually
- Specified health and education professionals
- Partners, parents and children of British Citizens
- Certain UK Ancestry routes
- Ten-year route: The default position to apply for settlement. Applicants would need to demonstrate that they have earned at least £12,571 per year over their qualifying period.
- Twenty-year route: Applicants who have committed immigration breaches or who have accessed specified Government benefits may find themselves on this qualifying route.
Integration and English language requirements
The Government has decided to assess an applicant’s integration through English language requirements and completion of the Life in the UK Test.
Whilst these are reflective of the current rules, the benchmark for the English language requirement has been increased from level B1 to level B2. The Government will not consider an English language level C1 or C2 to be a positive contributing factor, and will not make your qualifying period shorter.
Current exemptions will remain in place for children, those over the age of 65, and those with a physical or mental impediment.
Residence and qualifying visas
Under the proposed framework, the types of visas that count toward your qualifying period will change significantly, alongside the closure of the current Long Residence route.
Immigration routes that will no longer count towards settlement
Under the proposed framework, time spent in the UK on temporary immigration routes would no longer count towards settlement. This means that periods spent on visas such as:
- Visit visas
- Student visas
- Graduate visas
- Youth mobility visas
- Seasonal Worker visas
- Global Business Mobility routes
Immigration routes that will count towards settlement
Instead, you must demonstrate that you have spent time on a route that will count towards settlement, such as:
- Longer-term work, talent and family routes
- Specified talent and innovation routes
- Family and private life
How will the proposals affect family members?
Following feedback during the consultation, the Government has moved away from requiring family members to earn settlement entirely independently.
Partners who arrive at the same time as the main applicant will generally continue to be able to settle at the same time. Children under 18 will remain exempt from many of the mandatory requirements, including income thresholds, English language requirements and the Life in the UK Test.
Young adults aged between 18 and 24 may also continue to settle alongside their family in certain circumstances.
How will the proposals affect refugees and protection routes?
Refugees arriving through designated safe and legal routes would continue to benefit from a five-year route to settlement. However, those granted protection following an asylum claim made in the UK may face much longer settlement periods.
Illegal entry may result in an additional 10-year waiting period, taking the total qualifying period to 30 years, subject to the circumstances.
How we can help
Individuals who may be affected by these changes should seek specialist immigration advice to understand how any future reforms could impact their route to settlement and British citizenship.